Allstar Fuel Card Review: Is It the Right Fuel Card Provider for You?

Allstar has the widest petrol station network of any fuel card provider, plus a handy map tool for finding nearby petrol stations. This makes it one of the best fuel card companies for small to medium-sized business owners, such as minicab firms, private hire vehicles, coaches, HGV fleets, and national courier services.

Its compatibility with alternate fuel types and electric vehicle (EV) charging make it particularly suitable for large businesses which need to report on carbon emissions. Allstar cards are accepted at 120 motorway stations and 804 HGV friendly stations, which isn't as many as UK Fuels but it's more than Texaco or BP.

Known as Overdrive Business Solutions Ltd until 2005, Allstar is an industry-leading fuel card provider in the UK. With over 7,600 fuel card locations across the UK, Allstar is used by more than one million drivers, making it one of the most popular suppliers on the market.

But is it an all-star choice for your business? And how could it benefit your fleet management? We’ve looked into account features, card charges, customer satisfaction, and petrol station locations, saving you hours of research.

If you're looking to get started with Allstar, or fuel cards in general, you can receive free, zero-commitment quotes by using our comparison tool. By entering information about your business, we'll ask fuel card providers to call you back to discuss your business needs.

What are Allstar's fuel card options?

Allstar offers various types of fuel cards to suit businesses of all sizes. But how do they differ? And which types of vehicle do they suit best? Keep in mind, all of these fuel cards will offer the basic services of a logistics dashboard and discounts on fuel.

Allstar One Fuel Card: Best all-round Allstar fuel card

Allstar One Electric: Best for electric fleets

Allstar Supermarket Fuel Card: Best for small local businesses

Allstar Monitor Card: Best for public sector vehicles

Where are Allstar fuel cards accepted?

Allstar's network includes over 7,700 sites at various oil brands and supermarkets across the UK. This is a very solid amount, and you likely won't be left too far from a site at any given time. However, the density of these sites does vary based on geographic location.

If your fleet doesn't venture much outside of the southern half of England, you'll be well equipped to find an Allstar-compatible site, with well over half their UK spots being located in this region. However, if you venture into Wales, North England, Scotland, or Northern Ireland, you'll find the number of compatible sites dropping off noticeably. Make no mistake – they're still around, but just not as bountiful as in the south of England.

This number obviously falls when you consider certain requirements, like 24-hour service, or the ability to accommodate HGVs. However, the ratio is still roughly the same, with southern England having the most sites, while the northern UK has a drop off.

What are Allstar fuel cards' features and benefits?

Allstar offers some handy features and benefits to accompany its fuel cards. Let’s find out what’s on offer…

✓ Petrol station finder tool

Allstar accounts come with a handy map tool that helps drivers locate the nearest petrol station that accepts their fuel cards. This will save wasted fuel on driving around trying to find a refuelling point from memory.

✓ Streamline expenses management

You'll get HMRC-approved invoices that simplify your accounting. Digital invoices also provide you with a VAT breakdown.

✓ UK’s largest network 

You can use Allstar fuel cards at more than 7,700 fuel stations, which equates to over 90% of stations across the UK. This means your drivers will never be too far from a fuelling point, and ensures your fleet keeps running as smoothly as possible.

✓ Pay for alternative fuels

You can also use Allstar fuel cards to charge electric vehicles (EV) or fill up on hydrogen-based fuel at various ITM Power refuelling stations. This flexibility in purchase type is a seriously useful feature for fleets running on non-traditional fuels.

Can I use Allstar’s fuel cards in supermarkets?

Yes, you can use the Allstar Supermarket Fuel card to fill up at supermarket stations. Supermarket fuel is often a lot cheaper than motorway fuel and is fairly easy to find. This card covers 3,000+ fuel sites, 1,600 diesel sites, and covers 4 major supermarket brands.

What is the Allstar Fuel Card App Like?

Strangely, despite Allstar's general overall quality, their app is absolutely raked across the coals on both app stores, rated just 1.7/5 on the iOS App Store and 2.2/5 on the Google Play Store.

It's not an issue of being difficult to use or lacking features – almost every review states that the app simply doesn't work. Crashing, failing location tracking, broken features, these are all cited across multiple one-star reviews. Sadly the benefit of locating low-priced petrol stations isn't accessible to many through the app. We suggest you try Allstar's site locator through your web browser instead.

Maybe it used to work on older phones and hasn't been updated, maybe it was released without being finished in the first place. Either way, if the app was tweaked and reworked, it would be functional and useful, Allstar just needs to spend some time making sure it actually works on current gen iPhones and Androids.

How much do Allstar fuel cards cost?

There is no fixed pricing for using Allstar, because – as with most fuel card suppliers – you’ll need a bespoke quote to match the unique needs of your business. However, below we’ve highlighted some of the most important fees, to give you an idea of what you can expect to pay with Allstar.

Some other costs may apply, though the above is a list of the main ones. You should make sure you fully understand all the terms and conditions of Allstar fuel cards before you sign up for one.

How much can I save with Allstar Discount Diesel?

With UK gas prices in flux, the war in Russia contributing to a meteoric rise in costs, and now local councils increasingly charging diesel drivers up to triple the amount of electric vehicle parking, it's nice to be able to save on diesel costs where you can.

As diesel costs are steadily climbing (with a January 2022 national average of 124.9p per litre to a January 2023 national average of 170.6p per litre), Allstar's offer of saving approximately 7% of diesel costs is a prospect few would turn down.

To save money on diesel costs, you have to fill up at one of the 1,600 Diesel Discount stations and swipe your Allstar fuel card.

Is Allstar right for my business?

Allstar might be one of the UK’s leading fuel card suppliers, but it’s not the perfect option for every business. Find out whether it would suit yours below…

✔️ “My fleet’s vehicles use both petrol and diesel.”

Allstar caters to both petrol and diesel fuel, as well as alternative options like hydrogen-based fuel. If your fleet uses both petrol and diesel, then we’d recommend using the Allstar Premier Programme card.

✔️ “I hate handling invoices and paperwork.”

Allstar’s HMRC-approved invoices are a convenient way of keeping on top of your business accounting. Allstar's online portal is a handy way to keep all your fuel invoices digital and organised. If you prefer to keep things old school, you can even order a physical copy of your invoice at £9.99 apiece.

❌ “I don’t want to pay any transaction fees.”

While Allstar applies transaction fees up to £2.75 per transaction, most other large fuel card suppliers – like UK Fuels and Esso – don’t charge any. This could be something to think about when considering your overall expenditure on fuel cards. That’s why we’d always recommend comparing your fuel card options before making a choice.

What do Allstar reviews say?

Allstar fares somewhat poorly when it comes to reviews across the web. Before we go into specifics, however, it's worth remembering that these reviews are for Allstar as a business as a whole, not just their fuel cards.

On Trustpilot, Allstar has a 2.6/5 star rating. Strangely, this is largely split between five and one star reviews, which collectively make up 89% of their total reviews. As far as the positive reviews, the customer service is lauded, and that Allstar is overall an easy business to work with.

However, the negative reviews cite that the business charges a 26p fee on each litre purchased through their fuel cards, claiming that this came out of the blue. While a couple of reviews brought this up, our research found the so-called “convenience charge” should be no more than 6p per litre, according to the August 2022 Standard Charges (which is the latest statement of fees the company has released).

What are the best Allstar fuel card alternatives?

Even though it's one of our favourite providers, it's possible that Allstar isn't for you. Maybe the long list of fees has turned you off or perhaps you need more fuelling sites in the north of the UK. The good news is that they're not the only fuel card on the market, with cards being offered by companies like BP and Texaco.

No matter your qualms or preferences, there will be a fuel card provider for you. Have a look at our top fuel cards on the market to find the best option for your business.

Our Methodology

Our independent researchers compared 8 different providers to find the best fuel card on the market. Each provider was assessed based on the following criteria:

• Station coverage – the number of stations the fuel cards can be used at.
• Fees – some providers will charge a card fee, account fees, management fees, etc.
• Savings – depending on how much fuel you use, some providers will provide discounts which will often be higher the higher the fuel usage.